People mouth two skin, the same thing how to say how reasonable, but in law, but not vague concept, cunning can not get tolerance, some people always want to take shortcuts to obtain wealth, but often steal chicken can not erode rice, honest, no disaster, crooked evil way eventually wet shoes.

June 6, the case of "gun key buckle" which attracted much attention was sentenced to criminal punishment in the first instance of Anshan court in Liaoning Province. Three of them were sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of 3 to 4 years for illegal manufacturing, trading and mailing firearms. The defendant chose to appeal. Is this "key button" that can break through thin iron barrel count as a gun?

In 2012, Xiamen's Li, through the Internet, bought a gun shaped key fastener from abroad. He found it very fashionable and beautiful. He saw domestic demand. From 2013, he commissioned business partner Xu Mou to take the bought key button as the prototype for reproduction production.

Li sold online. His family was equipped with gunpowder and pellet. Although no injury happened, the ratio of the muzzle to kinetic energy of the key button exceeded the standard of 1.8 joules. Although the gun was only 4 cm in length and the bullet was only 2mm, it was still recognized as a gun.

On July 31st, 2018, Li was taken away from his home in Fujian Province for investigation. The detention notice received by his family showed that Li was detained for the crime of illegally selling guns. However, Ms. Chen, his wife, said that they sold key buttons, mainly for collection, with a price of only several hundred yuan, and no injuries occurred.

Ms. Chen said that although the gun key fastener is equipped with firing function, her husband does not do gunpowder and pellet, which is a collection type key hook for sale. After they sell it, they may make ammunition at home, but ammunition is also only guided into and out of the gun and other things, with the same composition as the match head.

This kind of simulation gun key buckle is not harmful. Ms. Chen said that although it can be played, it is far less powerful than a knife and bow arrow. Moreover, the so-called ammunition made by dealers is often dumb guns. In August 2015, local police inspected the key buttons, and they were told that the sale of the items was OK.

But some bloggers have demonstrated the power of the "gun key button". Although the gun key button is only 4cm, after the shot is fired in close range, the bullet can easily penetrate the thin iron barrel. If it is human skin and tissue, it is impossible to withstand the bullet from the key button.

The court of first instance held that Li, Xu and Liang were the main offenders, who illegally manufactured and sold guns, mailed 78 guns and 33 parts of guns. Their actions had constituted the crime of illegal manufacturing, trading and mailing guns. Because they did not cause serious harm and consequences, they were sentenced to three to four years.

The other 12 people were not punished for their minor crimes. Li's lawyer said the size of the articles involved was too small to be considered toys rather than guns from the point of view of the gun mark or caliber. His client, Li, had appealed, but it was difficult to say whether the appeal could be successful.

The appraisal report issued by the police shows that the gun key buckle submitted for inspection is a self-made pocket revolver powered by gunpowder, which belongs to non military guns, which has shooting function and is recognized as guns. It is said that Li and other people do not understand the law. Obviously, it is also wrong. If only making gun shaped keyclasp, why should we take the function of firing powder, which is incomprehensible.

But Li's wife said the truth. The gun shaped key buckle is not as harmful as a knife or bow and arrow. But it is not only about the degree of harm involved in gun. What do you think about this case.